You can switch off notifications anytime using browser settings.Stock Analysis, IPO, Mutual Funds, Bonds & MoreWhat started with the collapse of IL&FS last year is still having ripple effects in the market.Transparency, liquidity and prospects of better returns prompted chartered accountant Kuntal Parikh to move a substantial portion of his savings from banks tomutual fundsabout five years ago. Parikh enjoyed higher returns all these years, but is now moving a portion of his savings back to traditional bank deposits.
A series of defaults on borrowed sums by companies and their promoters, coupled with regulatory changes, eroded returns from mutual fund debt plans, leading investors to question whether risks outweigh the returns.
As recently as last week,UTI Mutual Fundand Reliance Nippon Asset Management sliced off the holdings of Altico Capital bonds after a default and suspended normal subscriptions and redemptions. Kotak Mutual Fund and Aditya Birla Mutual Fund faced similar pressures after some companies such as the Essel Group defaulted.
Debt corporate funds, which more than doubled in size in the past five years, have returned 7.08 per cent on an average in the period, compared with 6.25 per cent yielded now by State Bank of Indias fixed deposits. BankFDsare taxable, while bond investors get indexation benefits if instruments held for at least three years.
Crisil data showed that some mutual funds schemes from DSP, UTI, DHFL Pramerica and others have lost their entire value in the past one year, when funds wrote down the value of defaulting debt. This led earnings of many years to be eroded with just one or two defaults.
I have never thought that I would lose my principal amount in debt investments, said Parikh, a resident of Ahmedabad. This (value erosion) has changed my perception of debt products. I have shifted back to fixed deposits that would earn me less, but would be safe.
What started with the collapse of Infrastructure Leasing & Financial Services (IL&FS) last year is still having ripple effects in the market. Essel Group of Subhash Chandra, Vikram Thapars CG Power, Dewan Housing Finance and Sintex are among prominent defaulters to have hit mutual funds so far.
Events of the past year indebt mutual fundshave even irked the markets regulator.
The safety of investment cannot be compromised for want of higher yields, said Ajay Tyagi, chairman of the Securities & Exchange Board of India. While we have taken steps to restrict such investments, the industry as a whole needs to do its own analysis on a regular basis to avoid such situations in future.
After years of meagre growth since starting in the mid-90s, mutual funds had a blistering growth as they packaged the advantages of transparency and liquidity. At the click of a button was a slogan that traveled well into individual homes and corporate treasuries looking to beat market returns.
Debt mutual funds assets under management rose 85 per cent in August 2019 to about Rs 13.22 lakh crore from Rs 7.13 lakh crore in August 2014. Credit schemes to liquid schemes to plain vanilla corporate bond funds flourished as savings moved into debt plans.
While debt credit risk funds returned an average of 7.26 per cent in five years, the risk was also building up with indiscriminate borrowing that led to over-leverage. A sudden economic slowdown and halting of payments over disputes led to a credit squeeze, especially for infrastructure firms.
There is a trust deficit among investors, said Vikram Dalal, managing director at Synergee Capital, a Mumbai-based advisory firm. Investors are not investing any fresh funds into debt funds, as some NBFCs and mortgage firms have defaulted on their principal/ interest repayment. After the IL&FS episode, rating agencies have become very alert in assigning ratings.
Companies arbitraging interest rates borrowing short-term at lower rates and lending long for higher returns were given the stick by mutual funds. When they declined to roll over credit, funds became scarce. The likes of DHFL and Essel group were hit.
Of course, the funds bled. For example, Aditya Birla Mutual Fund invested Rs 2,220 crore in DHFL group companies as on September 30, 2018 which is worth Rs 55 lakh in August, showed data from Value Research. DSP Mutual Fund invested Rs 126.12 crore on September 30, 2018, in DHFL, which is now worth Rs 40.16 crore in July. Fund houses either marked down losses or exited investments in the secondary market.
Until about a year ago, the significant growth of the mutual fund industry was one of the most talked about success stories of capital markets in India, said Sebis Tyagi. The events last year, however, exposed the fault lines in the industry and showed that a credit event in even one issuer/group could have a contagion effect leading to liquidity risk across the market.
Investors and mutual funds were playing musical chairs. When the music stopped, they did not find an exit door in a market that was shallow and that did not have a proper valuation mechanism for these illiquid papers.
Much needs to be done on debt infrastructure, governance and accountability, said Ananth Narayan, professor of finance at SPJIMR. We need to increase the corporate bond repo market liquidity, increase debt secondary market volumes, improve accountability of rating companies, and strengthen credit departments of mutual funds.
The corporate debt market has grown to Rs 30.6 lakh crore by June this year from Rs 14.4 lakh crore in 2014, RBI data showed. Of this, the size of structured notes market has grown to Rs 23,000 crore from Rs 878 crore. But the trading volume is less than a crore a day in this segment.
The secondary market in corporate debt is so illiquid that we can very well say there is no such market, said BP Kanungo, deputy governor at the central bank.
While mutual funds have their own credit appraisal methods, a lot of it depended on rating companies that were caught napping. Two of the biggest defaults in the past year IL&FS and Dewan Housing carried triple A rating almost until they missed payments.
Naresh Thakkar was shown the door by ICRA, a unit of Moodys Investors Services, for his suspected role in meddling with rating actions.Sebihas come up with a new set of rules like disclosing near-period performance to capture their performance. This has led to quick and often overnight junking of some debt papers.
The rating transition of some corporate debt, particularly those issued by financial firms, has been phenomenal from sound credit to junk, said Kanungo.
While the regulator tightened rules for rating companies, it came up with a bail-out plan for the industry facing such troubles a concept called side pocketing where a fund can set aside the defaulted paper and redeem units at the net asset value minus the amount stuck with the defaulter.
This led to a sudden drop in the NAV of a scheme which faced a default from a borrower. Although investors may get whatever value the fund realises when a resolution happened, it hit at the very foundation of the mutual fund concept liquidity at the click of a button with pass through.
Side pocketing ensures that some investors can get a more-than-fair share of the funds real value and some can get a less-than-fair share, says Dhirendra Kumar, founder & CEO, Value Research, a mutual fund research company.
Every financial asset and investments in these instruments through mutual funds carry some risks. However, in India banks are a different class with the assumption of 100 per cent safety, although deposit insurance covers just about Rs 1 lakh of investments.
Given the RBIs undeclared commitment to protect depositors and nearly three-fourths of the banking system owned by the government, people take the safety of their funds as granted.
Although investors are used to see their NAVs in equity schemes fall dramatically over a period of time, they were unaccustomed to the erosion of value in debt funds.
We do not have a strong history of bond defaults, which have been happening in the past one year, said Kumar of Value Research. This is only a tiny portion when it compares with mammoth bank bad loans. The latest default is like a Delhi winter for a person, who has never experienced winter in true sense.
While investors get used to the risks associated with debt funds, the faith in the industry is being dented by the quick recourse to side pocketing and deals with defaulters for later payments.
Mutual funds as financial intermediaries have helped companies diversify their risk, reduce their borrowing costs, and help investors earn better returns. But the faith built over the past two decades needs to be maintained by ensuring practices that are transparent as investors digest the risks associated with such investments.
The tagline often associated with mutual funds is Mutual Funds Sahi Hai, said Tyagi. We ought to remember that it takes years to build trust in an industry and only a single event may erode it. So, there should be a collective effort by all stakeholders, including AMCs, trustees and Sebi to uphold and maintain that trust and faith.
(%)Mirae Asset Tax Saver Direct-G0.88-2.10-0.7313.4113.26Invest NowAxis Long Term Equity Direct-G5.513.626.8019.7412.69Invest NowMirae Asset Tax Saver Reg-G0.74-2.52-1.5911.4711.70Invest Now
– Returns less then 1 year are absolute and above 1 year are annualised.
– Returns of 1 year are absolute and above 1 year are annualised..
What is waterfall valuation approach in debt mutual funds?
Start Investing with ICICI Prudential Mutual Fund. Click Here
Commenting feature is disabled in your country/region.
DownloadThe Economic Times Business News Appfor the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
OnePlus 7 (Mirror Grey, 6GB RAM, Optic AMOLED Display, 128GB Storage, 3700mAH Battery)
OnePlus 7 Pro (Mirror Grey, 6GB RAM, Fluid AMOLED Display, 128GB Storage, 4000mAH Battery)
Debt mutual fund managers react to RBI policy
What is waterfall valuation approach in debt mutual funds?
Copyright © 2019 Bennett, Coleman & Co. Ltd. All rights reserved. For reprint rights:Times Syndication Service
Mid and small cap mutual funds may make a comeback, but dont rush to invest
Dont view gold as an asset class to meet long-term financial goals
Investing in equity mutual funds via SIP for a five-year goal? Be prepared for a shock
Why are direct investors unsure about their mutual fund investments?
Investors should use the recent decline to allocate to equities
SIP inflows into equity schemes continue unabated in September
Mrinal Singh of ICICI Pru Mutual Fund on recent underperformance of Value Discovery Fund
It is the time to invest in small and mid cap mutual funds via SIP: Yogesh Bhatt of ICICI Pru MF
Equity mutual fund inflow hits 4-month low in Sep on profit booking
Mutual funds witness net outflows in September, SIP flows continue to rise
Choose your reason below and click on the Report button. This will alert our moderators to take action